20 Best Apple Butter Substitutes [2024]

Are you looking for the best apple butter substitutes? Based on expert reviews, we ranked them. We've listed our top-ranked picks, including the top-selling apple butter substitutes.

We Recommended:

# Preview Product
1 Tap'n Apple Apple Butter Spread, 18 Ounce Jar Tap'n Apple Apple Butter Spread, 18 Ounce Jar
2 Eden Foods Apple Butter, Og, 17-Ounce (Pack of 3) Eden Foods Apple Butter, Og, 17-Ounce (Pack of 3)
3 Red Oak Provisions Apple Butter Spread - All Natural - Great for Gift Basket Sets - 19 oz. Red Oak Provisions Apple Butter Spread - All Natural - Great for Gift Basket Sets - 19 oz.
4 Mrs Miller's Amish Homemade All Natural Apple Butter 18 Ounces - 2 Jars (No Corn Sugar) Mrs Miller's Amish Homemade All Natural Apple Butter 18 Ounces - 2 Jars (No Corn Sugar)
5 Oats Overnight - Party Pack Variety (8 Meals PLUS BlenderBottle ) High Protein, Low Sugar Breakfast... Oats Overnight - Party Pack Variety (8 Meals PLUS BlenderBottle ) High Protein, Low Sugar...
6 Sweets, Holidays and Family Recipes - Israeli-Mediterranean Cookbook (Cook In Israel - Kosher... Sweets, Holidays and Family Recipes - Israeli-Mediterranean Cookbook (Cook In Israel - Kosher...
7 Zero Sugar Cookbook Zero Sugar Cookbook
8 That's it. Apple + Mango 100% Natural Real Fruit Bar, Best High Fiber Vegan, Gluten Free Healthy... That's it. Apple + Mango 100% Natural Real Fruit Bar, Best High Fiber Vegan, Gluten Free Healthy...
9 Musselman's Apple Butter Musselman's Apple Butter
10 EDEN® ORGANIC APPLE BUTTER 17 OZ EDEN® ORGANIC APPLE BUTTER 17 OZ
11 PBfit All-Natural Peanut Butter Powder, Powdered Peanut Spread From Real Roasted Pressed Peanuts, 8g... PBfit All-Natural Peanut Butter Powder, Powdered Peanut Spread From Real Roasted Pressed Peanuts,...
12 BARNEY Almond Butter, Bare Smooth, No Stir, No Sugar, No Salt, Non-GMO, Skin-Free, Paleo, KETO, 16... BARNEY Almond Butter, Bare Smooth, No Stir, No Sugar, No Salt, Non-GMO, Skin-Free, Paleo, KETO,...
13 Musselman's Apple Butter (2 Pack, Total of 34oz) Musselman's Apple Butter (2 Pack, Total of 34oz)
14 Bobo's Oat Bars Original, 12 Pack of 3 oz Bars Gluten Free Whole Grain Rolled Oat Bar - Great... Bobo's Oat Bars Original, 12 Pack of 3 oz Bars Gluten Free Whole Grain Rolled Oat Bar - Great...
15 VEGETABLES!: Simple and Easy Vegetable Crock Pot Recipes VEGETABLES!: Simple and Easy Vegetable Crock Pot Recipes
16 The Vitamix Cookbook: 250 Delicious Whole Food Recipes to Make in Your Blender The Vitamix Cookbook: 250 Delicious Whole Food Recipes to Make in Your Blender
17 Amish Wedding No Sugar Added Apple Butter 18 Ounces (Pack of 2) Amish Wedding No Sugar Added Apple Butter 18 Ounces (Pack of 2)
18 NU-SALT Substitute, Sodium-free, 3 Oz (3 Pack) NU-SALT Substitute, Sodium-free, 3 Oz (3 Pack)
19 Field Trip Chickpea Butter | Healthy Vegan Snacks, Gluten Free, Non GMO, All Natural Creamy Almond... Field Trip Chickpea Butter | Healthy Vegan Snacks, Gluten Free, Non GMO, All Natural Creamy...
20 Lakanto Classic Monk Fruit Sweetener with Erythritol - White Sugar Substitute, Zero Calorie, Keto... Lakanto Classic Monk Fruit Sweetener with Erythritol - White Sugar Substitute, Zero Calorie, Keto...
Bestseller No. 1
Tap'n Apple Apple Butter Spread, 18 Ounce Jar
  • The package dimension of the product is 6"L x 5"W x 4"H
  • The package weight of the product is 1.8 pounds
Bestseller No. 3
Red Oak Provisions Apple Butter Spread - All Natural - Great for Gift Basket Sets - 19 oz.
  • 🍎 Full of Flavor – Red Oak Provisions’ old fashioned, slow simmered apple butter captures apples in their essence. It has an intense...
  • 🍎 Multiple Uses – Apple butter is most commonly used for spreading on toast, biscuits, scones and breads. It can be served with crackers...
  • 🍎 Perfect Gift –Red Oak Provisions’ Apple Butter makes a great gift for anyone who loves the taste of apples. Great for a peanut butter...
  • 🍎 A Product you Can Trust –We are a small, family-owned business that strives to help our customers every day. If you have an issue with...
Bestseller No. 4
Mrs Miller's Amish Homemade All Natural Apple Butter 18 Ounces - 2 Jars (No Corn Sugar)
  • 2 DELIGHTFUL JARS OF DELICIOUS Homemade Amish Apple Butter - 18 Ounces Each Jar
  • MADE WITH FRESH RIPENED APPLES, this naturally sweetened Apple Butter is similar to regular Apple Butter except it is sweetened with apple cider...
  • APPLE BUTTER is a highly concentrated form of applesauce; it's cooked slow and long so that the sugar in the apples caramelize and turn the sauce a...
  • NON GMO, Corn Syrup Free, Dairy Free, Gluten Free. Hand scooped in Ohio's Amish Country. MADE IN THE USA! Made from the Freshest All-Natural...
  • YOU WILL RECEIVE: 2 - 18 oz Mrs. Miller's Amish Homemade All Natural Apple Butter in your purchase. SHIPS IN A CORRUGATED BOX To Help Ensure...
Bestseller No. 5
Oats Overnight - Party Pack Variety (8 Meals PLUS BlenderBottle ) High Protein, Low Sugar Breakfast...
  • ZERO MORNING PREP - Mix one packet of Oats Overnight with your choice of milk substitute (or traditional milk) the night before and place in the...
  • GLUTEN FREE, LOW SUGAR, NON-GMO - Made with certified gluten free 100% whole grain oats and premium ingredients like bananas, strawberries, green...
  • NUTRITIOUS START TO YOUR DAY - Each serving contains 20G+ of protein, 6g+ of fiber and less than 9g of sugar. Guaranteed to keep you full until...
  • 20G+ OF LEAN PROTEIN - Making it the perfect complete breakfast meal replacement or a recovery smoothie or shake after your workout.
  • 8 DELICIOUS FLAVORS - Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana, Strawberries & Cream, Green Apple Cinnamon, Mocha Dream (which contains coffee!), Peach Upside...
Bestseller No. 6
Sweets, Holidays and Family Recipes - Israeli-Mediterranean Cookbook (Cook In Israel - Kosher...
  • Amazon Kindle Edition
  • Ziv, Orly (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 100 Pages - 12/25/2013 (Publication Date)
SaleBestseller No. 7
Zero Sugar Cookbook
  • Hardcover Book
  • Zinczenko, David (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 272 Pages - 12/31/2018 (Publication Date) - Ballantine Books (Publisher)
Bestseller No. 8
That's it. Apple + Mango 100% Natural Real Fruit Bar, Best High Fiber Vegan, Gluten Free Healthy...
  • JUST APPLE + MANGO SERIOUSLY, THAT’S IT! We’re packing 2 REAL fruit servings in a delicious, chewy fruit bar that delights your taste buds and...
  • HEALTHY SNACKING ON THE GO: 87% of Americans are not getting their daily recommended fruit intake, so toss That’s It. Fruit Bars in your gym bag or...
  • 2-YEAR SHELF LIFE: An estimated 60% of all produce is wasted each year due to spoilage, fruit bugs, peelings, etc. so all of our fruit bars have a...
  • 100% NATURAL: Ingredient lists have never been this simple and clean. Manufactured free from the top 12 allergens, That’s It. Fruit Bars are...
  • TRY THEM ALL: We make it convenient and fun to get your two whole servings of fruit just from one That’s It. Fruit Bar. No washing or peeling...
Bestseller No. 10
EDEN® ORGANIC APPLE BUTTER 17 OZ
  • Organic, Macrobiotic, Vegan, Kosher, Gluten-Free
Bestseller No. 11
PBfit All-Natural Peanut Butter Powder, Powdered Peanut Spread From Real Roasted Pressed Peanuts, 8g...
  • Protein power: with 8g of protein in one serving of Original PBfit, you can get a boost of protein right after your workout at the gym. Try adding it...
  • Simple ingredients: original PBfit is made with 3 simple ingredients: peanuts, coconut palm sugar, and salt. Did we mention it's all natural and...
  • Deliciousness defined: for a tasty, reduced-fat peanut butter spread, mix 2 Tbsp. Of dry PBfit with 1.5 Tbsp. Of water. Stir until smooth, and spread...
  • Blend, bake, or shake: when it comes to the uses for PBfit, The possibilities are endless! Mix into baked goods like bread, pancakes, waffles, and...
  • Same great taste: due to new FDA guidelines on serving sizes, one serving of PBfit is now updated from 12g to 16g. It now contains 8g of protein, has...
Bestseller No. 12
BARNEY Almond Butter, Bare Smooth, No Stir, No Sugar, No Salt, Non-GMO, Skin-Free, Paleo, KETO, 16...
  • SKIN-FREE, CALIFORNIA ALMONDS – We blanch premium California almonds to remove the skin to produce an ultra-smooth, no-stir, grit-free texture
  • BARE ESSENTIALS - Only two ingredients - Blanched Roasted Almond and Palm Fruit Oil; the same great taste without added sugar or salt
  • NON-GMO - Our small-batch blends use only the finest ingredients
  • ALLERGEN FREE – Peanut-Free, Gluten-Free, Soy-Free, Dairy-Free, Egg-Free
  • FITS YOUR LIFESTYLE - Clean eating plant based protein that is certified Paleo, KETO, Vegan and Kosher
SaleBestseller No. 13
Musselman's Apple Butter (2 Pack, Total of 34oz)
  • In 1928, Christian and Emma Mussselman built a preserves plant in Biglerville, Pennsylvania.
  • As a twist, dip chicken fingers or sweet potatoes fries in apple butter.
  • Add apple butter to smoothies or oatmeal.
  • Spread apple butter and peanut butter on crackers for a quick snatch.
  • No High Fructose Corn Syrup
Bestseller No. 14
Bobo's Oat Bars Original, 12 Pack of 3 oz Bars Gluten Free Whole Grain Rolled Oat Bar - Great...
  • Contains 12 Bobo's Oat Bars (3oz each)
  • Non-GMO, Gluten Free, Dairy Free, Vegan: Free of wheat, meat, soy, dairy, GMOs, trans fats, refined sugars, and corn
  • Simple, Wholesome, Organic Ingredients: Lower number of ingredients compared to most other whole grain oat brands
  • Handmade Baked Goods: Baked fresh in Boulder Colorado, Made in the USA
  • Whole Grain Rolled Oats: All Bobo’s products start with 1 simple ingredient that supports lactation and breast milk supply
Bestseller No. 15
VEGETABLES!: Simple and Easy Vegetable Crock Pot Recipes
  • Amazon Kindle Edition
  • Scott, Hannie P. (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 46 Pages - 09/10/2014 (Publication Date) - Hannie P. Publishing (Publisher)
SaleBestseller No. 16
The Vitamix Cookbook: 250 Delicious Whole Food Recipes to Make in Your Blender
  • William Morrow Company
  • Hardcover Book
  • Berg, Jodi (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 400 Pages - 10/13/2015 (Publication Date) - William Morrow Cookbooks (Publisher)
Bestseller No. 18
NU-SALT Substitute, Sodium-free, 3 Oz (3 Pack)
  • Contains potassium chloride
  • Potassium chloride = is the salt substitute component of the blend
  • Use it just like salt on all your favorite foods
Bestseller No. 19
Field Trip Chickpea Butter | Healthy Vegan Snacks, Gluten Free, Non GMO, All Natural Creamy Almond...
  • HOW TO EAT: Tastes like a Nut Butter - with NO NUTS. Replace the traditional use of peanut butter in any form when eating a PB&J (AKA: Chickpea Butter...
  • CLAIMS: Top 8 Allergen Free Facility, Vegan, Kosher Certified, Non-GMO Project Verified, Sustainably Harvested Organically Palm Oil (RSPO Certified),...
  • INGREDIENTS: Made up of healthy plant-based ingredients to make the most delicious new vegan spread on the block.
  • FLAVORS: Indulge in our chickpea butter as a healthy, slightly sweet snack. Fresh tasting and full of fun flavor. Try all of our flavors! Cinnamon...
  • SCHOOL LUNCH GO-TO: Grab a jar and never worry about what you’re going to pack for your kiddo's lunch.
Bestseller No. 20
Lakanto Classic Monk Fruit Sweetener with Erythritol - White Sugar Substitute, Zero Calorie, Keto...
  • Great for Cooking and Baking: White sugar substitute that's perfect for cookies, coffee, desserts, and other sweet, sugar-free treats. Tastes, bakes,...
  • Matches the Sweetness of Sugar: A healthy cup-for-cup alternative to ordinary sugar. Monk fruit contains zero calories and is about 250 times sweeter...
  • Lifestyle Friendly: Works with ketogenic, diabetic, candida, paleo, vegan, low-sugar, non-GMO, and all-natural diets. Monk fruit sweetener may help...
  • Sweet with No Guilt, Zero Glycemic Response: Contains zero net carbs, zero calories, and is zero-glycemic. Monk fruit sweetener is safe for most...
  • Lakanto's Mission Statement: At Lakanto, our mission is to Bring Chi to Life by inspiring people to reach their highest potential in health and...

Having trouble finding a great apple butter substitutes?

This problem is well understood by us because we have gone through the entire apple butter substitutes research process ourselves, which is why we have put together a comprehensive list of the best apple butter substitutess available in the market today.

After hours of searching and using all the models on the market, we have found the best apple butter substitutes for 2023. See our ranking below!

How Do You Buy The Best Apple Butter Substitutes?

Do you get stressed out thinking about shopping for a great apple butter substitutes? Do doubts keep creeping into your mind?

We understand, because we’ve already gone through the whole process of researching apple butter substitutes, which is why we have assembled a comprehensive list of the greatest apple butter substitutes available in the current market. We’ve also come up with a list of questions that you probably have yourself.

John Harvards has done the best we can with our thoughts and recommendations, but it’s still crucial that you do thorough research on your own for apple butter substitutes that you consider buying. Your questions might include the following:

  • Is it worth buying an apple butter substitutes?
  • What benefits are there with buying an apple butter substitutes?
  • What factors deserve consideration when shopping for an effective apple butter substitutes?
  • Why is it crucial to invest in any apple butter substitutes, much less the best one?
  • Which apple butter substitutes are good in the current market?
  • Where can you find information like this about apple butter substitutes?

We’re convinced that you likely have far more questions than just these regarding apple butter substitutes, and the only real way to satisfy your need for knowledge is to get information from as many reputable online sources as you possibly can.

Potential sources can include buying guides for apple butter substitutes, rating websites, word-of-mouth testimonials, online forums, and product reviews. Thorough and mindful research is crucial to making sure you get your hands on the best-possible apple butter substitutes. Make sure that you are only using trustworthy and credible websites and sources.

John Harvards provides an apple butter substitutes buying guide, and the information is totally objective and authentic. We employ both AI and big data in proofreading the collected information.

How did we create this buying guide? We did it using a custom-created selection of algorithms that lets us manifest a top-10 list of the best available apple butter substitutes currently available on the market.

This technology we use to assemble our list depends on a variety of factors, including but not limited to the following:

  1. Brand Value: Every brand of apple butter substitutes has a value all its own. Most brands offer some sort of unique selling proposition that’s supposed to bring something different to the table than their competitors.
  2. Features: What bells and whistles matter for an apple butter substitutes?
  3. Specifications: How powerful they are can be measured.
  4. Product Value: This simply is how much bang for the buck you get from your apple butter substitutes.
  5. Customer Ratings: Number ratings grade apple butter substitutes objectively.
  6. Customer Reviews: Closely related to ratings, these paragraphs give you first-hand and detailed information from real-world users about their apple butter substitutes.
  7. Product Quality: You don’t always get what you pay for with an apple butter substitutes, sometimes less, and sometimes more.
  8. Product Reliability: How sturdy and durable an apple butter substitutes is should be an indication of how long it will work out for you.

John Harvards always remembers that maintaining apple butter substitutes information to stay current is a top priority, which is why we are constantly updating our websites. Learn more about us using online sources.

If you think that anything we present here regarding apple butter substitutes is irrelevant, incorrect, misleading, or erroneous, then please let us know promptly!

Related Post:

FAQ:

Q: Is apple butter better for you than jelly?

A: While it does contain apples, apple butter is very high in sugar and calories, making it a less healthy option. However, it is still healthier than jelly since it is made with whole apples and thus contains a small amount of fiber.

Q: What is a good alternative to butter?

A: Weber emphasized that margarines sold in the U.S. today are healthier than they used to be, but they should still be consumed in moderation because they contain some saturated fat and a high amount of calories per serving size.

Q: Can you replace apple butter with apple sauce?

A: Replace all of the butter with an equal amount of unsweetened applesauce for the lowest-fat product. For instance, if your recipe calls for 1/2 cup butter, use 1/2 cup applesauce. To maximize taste and texture while still decreasing fat considerably, leave in about a quarter of the butter and substitute out the remainder.

Q: How much butter should you use instead of butter extract?

A: You can use melted butter as a direct 1:1 substitute for oil, but only up to a point. Because butter contains up to 15 percent water, if you’re making more than a single recipe, that moisture makes a difference. For double batches of a scratch cake or two boxes of mix, you may find it best to reduce your liquids by a couple of tablespoons for every cup of butter you use.